Chapter 16: Tumor Heterogeneity and Mass Cytometry

The complexity of cancer has long been a formidable challenge in both research and treatment. Mass cytometry has emerged as a powerful tool to unravel this complexity, offering unprecedented insights into tumor heterogeneity. Let’s explore how this technology is revolutionizing our understanding of cancer and paving the way for more effective treatments.

Revealing Intratumoral Heterogeneity

Tumors are not homogeneous masses of identical cells, but rather complex ecosystems comprising diverse cell populations. Mass cytometry allows us to dissect this heterogeneity with remarkable precision.

The groundbreaking work of Levine et al. (2015) in acute myeloid leukemia (AML) exemplifies the power of mass cytometry in this realm. By analyzing 31 proteins simultaneously in individual AML cells, they uncovered previously unrecognized cellular subpopulations, including a rare population of cells with progenitor-like features that correlated with poor prognosis.

First paper on CyTOF

In our own work (Beyrend et al., 2019), “PD-L1 blockade engages tumor-infiltrating lymphocytes to co-express targetable activating and inhibitory receptors,” we used mass cytometry to reveal the complex dynamics of T cell responses to immunotherapy. We found that PD-L1 blockade led to the emergence of T cell populations co-expressing both activating and inhibitory receptors, highlighting the intricate balance of immune regulation within the tumor microenvironment.

Building on this, in our subsequent study (Beyrend et al., 2023), “OX40 agonism enhances PD-L1 checkpoint blockade by shifting the cytotoxic T cell differentiation spectrum,” we further elucidated how combination immunotherapy reshapes the T cell landscape. Mass cytometry allowed us to track the differentiation trajectories of cytotoxic T cells, revealing how OX40 agonism synergizes with PD-L1 blockade to enhance anti-tumor immunity.

Identification of Rare Cell Populations

One of the most powerful applications of mass cytometry in cancer research is its ability to identify rare cell populations that may play crucial roles in tumor progression or treatment resistance.

For instance, in the study “An Immune Atlas of Clear Cell Renal Cell Carcinoma”, the authors used mass cytometry to profile the immune landscape of clear cell renal cell carcinoma (ccRCC). They analyzed 73 tumor and 5 normal kidney samples using a 29-marker panel, which allowed them to identify 17 tumor-associated macrophage phenotypes, 22 T cell phenotypes, and a distinct immune composition correlated with progression-free survival.

Importantly, they discovered a novel CD38+CD204+CD206+ macrophage population that was enriched in ccRCC and associated with an immunosuppressive environment. This macrophage subset could potentially serve as a new target for immunotherapy in renal cell carcinoma.

Another exciting example comes from Pellin et al. (2019), published in Nature. Their study, “Comprehensive single-cell profiling of human hematopoietic malignancies,” used mass cytometry alongside other single-cell technologies to create an atlas of hematological malignancies. They identified rare cell populations that drive disease progression and uncovered new potential therapeutic targets.

Progression and transcriptional trajectories dicoveries

Implications for Cancer Treatment

The insights gained from mass cytometry studies have profound implications for cancer treatment:

  1. Personalized Medicine: By revealing the unique cellular composition of each tumor, mass cytometry enables more personalized treatment strategies. For example, our work on combination immunotherapy suggests that patients might benefit from tailored approaches targeting specific T cell subsets.
  2. Response Mechanisms: Mass cytometry can help identify cell populations correlated with immunotherapy response. A study by Gide et al. (2023) in Cancer Cell, “Distinct Immune Cell Populations Define Response to Anti-PD-1 Monotherapy and Anti-PD-1/Anti-CTLA-4 Combined Therapy,” used mass cytometry to uncover immune cell populations associated with response to immunotherapy.
  3. Novel Therapeutic Targets: By uncovering previously unknown cell populations, mass cytometry opens up new avenues for therapeutic intervention. The tissue-resident memory T cells identified by Okla et al. (2021) represent a potential new target for enhancing anti-tumor immunity.
  4. Treatment Monitoring: Mass cytometry allows for detailed monitoring of treatment responses at the cellular level. This can help in early identification of responders and non-responders, enabling timely adjustments to treatment strategies.
  5. Combination Therapies: As demonstrated in our OX40 agonism study, mass cytometry can reveal synergistic effects of combination therapies, guiding the development of more effective treatment regimens.
Linking cell phenotype and progression free survival

In the world of tumor research, a funny thing happened: suddenly, knowing your cells wasn't enough. You had to speak 'computer' too. Picture this: on one side, you've got scientists peering at tumors through microscopes. On the other, data analysts crunch numbers, wondering if a cell is round or square (spoiler: it's neither). The gap between them? Wider than the Grand Canyon. That's when it hit me: to really understand tumors, we need to be bilingual. Fluent in both biology and coding. It's like being a translator between cells and computers. So there I was, juggling pipettes and Python, trying to teach my computer about cells and my cells about computers. Crazy? Maybe. Necessary? Absolutely. Because in the end, the best tumor insights come when biology and coding join forces. It's not just about looking at cells or crunching numbers – it's about doing both, and doing them well.

author avatar
Dr. Guillaume Beyrend-Frizon Scientist - Physician
Dr. Guillaume Beyrend-Frizon is an MD-PhD researcher and creator of the Cytofast R package, with 15 peer-reviewed publications in Cell Reports Medicine, JITC, and JoVE focusing on immunotherapy and advanced cytometry analysis. Through LearnCytometry.com, he has trained over 500 scientists worldwide in R-based cytometry analysis, translating cutting-edge research into practical educational tools that provide cost-effective alternatives to expensive commercial software.
Scroll to Top